Brexit And The Ghosts Of Christmas Past

Authored by Finian Cunningham by way of The Strategic Tradition Basis,

Given the season, it appears applicable to solid the Brexit saga in a Dickensian gentle.

‘A Christmas Carol’ (revealed 1843) was maybe Charles Dickens most celebrated novel, that includes a miserly central character, Ebenezer Scrooge, who was haunted by ghosts from the previous. The Brexit course of has actually loads of recriminations and miserliness to go round, in addition to having the theme of previous occasions being certain up within the current imbroglio.

British premier Theresa Might, along with her angular facial options, stern matron-like persona and suggestive surname, even resonates like a Dickens’ character. Her dithering and fumbling over Britain’s exit from the European Union is a combination of comedy, treachery and tragedy.

Might went to Brussels final week with cap-in-hand to beg for last-minute concessions from the EU leaders, solely to be informed – politely – to close up and get on with it. There can be no renegotiation of the withdrawal plan which she agreed to solely final month. Might now has the unenviable activity of attempting to get her Brexit roadmap handed by British parliamentarians. She cancelled tabling a vote final week, fearing that it will be resoundingly rejected by lawmakers.

With the Christmas parliamentary recess looming, it appears like Might should wait till mid-January earlier than lastly letting parliament have a say. If rejected, which appears possible, then Britain might face a no-deal crash out of the EU on the deadline for divorce set for March 29. However such is the alarm among the many public, politicians and media a few “exhausting Brexit”, and the dire financial repercussions of that, there could also be a dramatic U-turn in retailer, during which a second nationwide referendum is named on whether or not Britain ought to go away the EU or not. Briefly, Brexit might not occur in spite of everything.

This week, nevertheless, Prime Minister Might categorically dominated out requires a second referendum, saying that it will trigger “irreparable injury to the integrity of our politics”. She stated it will “break the general public religion” in British democracy. Within the Brexit referendum held in June 2016, a complete of 17.four million folks (52 per cent of the voters) solid their votes for Britain to depart the European bloc. The stay vote was 16.1 million (48 per cent).

Thus if a second referendum had been held and the vote was reversed, then the Brexit divorce mess could be averted, however the injury to Britain’s picture of democracy can be shattered. It might even set off civil unrest and sow deeper, extra bitter divisions which have already fractured the so-called United Kingdom.

Britain is caught in a fiendish dilemma. There appears to be no good choices out there. If it crashes out of the EU that can trigger uproar in half of the inhabitants. If it aborts Brexit and returns to the European fold with tail between legs, that can trigger related uproar within the different half of the inhabitants.

Again to our Dickens’ seasonal theme what’s hanging on this conundrum is how a lot the predicament is doomed by ghosts from the previous that are paralyzing ahead motion.

The primary of those ghosts is the 2008 world monetary disaster, the mishandling of which by the British governments and the EU government was a significant component in why the Brexit vote manifested. Because the world crash, it has been the mass of working individuals who have been made to pay for the failure in finance capitalism. Relentless polices of financial austerity – as an alternative of punitive reparations imposed on massive banks – have alienated odd residents in Britain and throughout the EU in the direction of the “institution”. This appears significantly acute in Britain as a result of successive Conservative governments there have pursued such stringent austerity financial insurance policies. So, when the Brexit referendum was held on June 23, 2016, the political institutions each in London and Brussels had been primed for a large public rebuke. That got here within the type of a convincing Go away vote.

An anti-immigrant sentiment and need for “management over our borders” was additionally an element within the Brexit vote. However once more that issue was a direct results of coverage. The unlawful wars that Britain and different European NATO members adopted america in waging, from Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and, covertly, in Syria, all fed into an exceptional migration problem throughout Europe.

In Britain, Labour and Conservative governments alike had been all complicit in these legal navy escapades of regime change. Nevertheless it was the Tory authorities of former Prime Minister David Cameron that bears a lot accountability from taking a lead position within the NATO battle to overthrow Libyan chief Muammar Gaddafi in 2011 which opened up mass migration routes to Europe. It was Cameron who assented to holding the Brexit referendum for his personal egocentric political causes (extra on that under). The vote for Brexit was at the very least partly a results of Cameron’s warmongering in Libya and different unlawful British wars elsewhere.

On the rise of anti-immigrant sentiment in Britain which partly drove the vote to depart the EU, the current prime minister can be culpable. Earlier than taking on as premier from Cameron in July 2016 (he stop over the Brexit outcome), Theresa Might served because the House Secretary (inside minister). Throughout her six-year submit as a hawkish inside minister, British authorities coverage grew to become sharply hostile in the direction of unlawful migrants. It was Might who launched public campaigns warning undocumented migrants to “go residence or face jail”.

Somewhat than being held to account for its legal wars in Central Asia, the Center East and North Africa – and the reason for refugee flows – the British authorities opted as an alternative to criminalize undocumented migrants. That inevitably fed into British public sentiment both fearing or loathing a notion of foreigners flooding into the nation. That prejudice was vented at EU membership when the Brexit referendum was held. Might and her Conservative governments had unleashed these sentiments with cynical dog-whistling racial politics.

One other ghost from the previous was the rise of the anti-EU, anti-immigrant United Kingdom Unbiased Social gathering (UKIP). UKIP has since fizzled into near-oblivion. However at one stage, the Eurosceptic celebration threatened to attract giant votes from the principle rightwing celebration, the Conservatives. In a determined transfer to fend off the UKIP, former Conservative premier David Cameron made a manifesto promise within the 2015 nationwide elections that, if he was reelected, his authorities would maintain a referendum on EU membership. Cameron thus used the Brexit difficulty as a option to maintain his celebration in energy and to push again the electoral risk of UKIP. A 12 months later, the Brexit vote then threw British politics into the turmoil that’s ongoing.

Lastly, our remaining ghost from the previous goes again a bit additional in historical past. It’s the legacy of British imperialist misdeeds in Eire. Britain’s violation of Eire’s sovereignty and its legal partitioning (1921) of the neighboring island nation is the predominant spanner within the Brexit wheels. The London authorities can not exit Europe simply – certainly will probably be mission not possible – due to the historic drawback regarding a British-imposed border in Eire.

The vast majority of folks on the island of Eire, each within the southern state, the Republic of Eire, and within the northern British jurisdiction of Northern Eire, are not looking for the return of a tough border. Neither does the European Union wish to create such a frontier, which might trigger immense disruption to all the Irish economic system. But when there is no such thing as a border, then a part of the UK (Northern Eire) will in impact stay built-in with the EU when it comes to customs and commerce. For the Brexiteers in Britain that’s anathema. The insoluble drawback of the Irish border is why the Brexit course of will ceaselessly be strapped with interminable wrangling and why the present British political disaster will proceed indefinitely.

The miserly previous of British politicians has come again to hang-out the current cohort into paralysis over Brexit.

Not like for the repentant imply Scrooge character in Dickens’ novel, there appears to be no redemption within the offing for the incumbent British political class.

Staff Writer
The above article is by a guest contributor, or shared from another news outlet.